Nagle’s Bagels Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Step into Nagle’s Bagels, your Brooklyn sanctuary for breakfast and brunch. Nestled at 378 Tompkins Ave, this vibrant spot offers a delightful array of bagels and spreads that locals rave about. Their menu shines with classic options like the Nagle’s Sunrise and The Gotham, where each bite is a perfect balance of flavors. The Jalapeño Cheddar and whole wheat Everything bagels serve as the foundation for savory sandwiches, bringing comfort and satisfaction.

  • Indulge in unique cream cheese varieties, such as the Garlic & Herb and Lox & Chive.
  • Vegetarians will love the Veggie Nagle, featuring goat cheese and tomato jam.
  • Enjoy a cozy atmosphere with outdoor seating and friendly service.

Nagle’s isn’t just about fantastic food—it’s a community hub that enhances the neighborhood experience. Stop by for a bagel and soak in the inviting energy. Your taste buds will thank you!

Bagel Choices Choose One Of Our Delicious Sandwiches Choice of Pastries Choose Hot Coffee Size Choose A Size Choice Of Drink Choose Flavor Choose Quantity 4oz. Cream Cheese 8oz. Cream Cheese Fish Retail

Bagel Choices

Everything
$2.40

Egg Everything
$2.40

Whole Wheat Everything
$2.40

Multigrain
$2.40

Plain
$2.40

Sesame
$2.40

Poppyseed
$2.40

Garlic
$2.40

Egg
$2.40

Pumpernickel
$2.40

Salt
$2.40

Jalapeo Cheddar
$2.40

Cinnamon Raisin
$2.40

Blueberry
$2.40

French Toast Bagel
$2.40

GLUTEN FREE Everything
$4.40

Nagles Sunrise

Fresh Fried Eggs, Sausage Patty, White Cheddar With Your Choice Of Sweet Chili Jam, Chipotle Mayo or Ketchup
$9.00

New Yorker

Fresh Fried Eggs, Applewood Smoked Bacon, White Cheddar With Your Choice Of Sweet Chili Jam, Chipotle Mayo or Ketchup
$9.00

Nagles Special

Fresh Fried Egg, Smoked Ham, Tomato, Onions & Sweet Chili Jam
$10.00

The Blue Velvet

Blueberry or Strawberry Cream Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Sweet Chili Jam, Goat Cheese, Tomato & Arugula
$11.00

Veggie Nagle

Fresh Fried Eggs, Goat Cheese, Avocado, Arugula & Sweet Chili Jam
$10.00

Egg & Cheese Plus

Fresh Fried Eggs, White Cheddar With Your Choice of Sweet Chili Jam, Chipotle Mayo or Ketchup
$8.00

Classic Nagle

Sliced Smoked Salmon, Plain Cream Cheese, Capers, Tomato, Red Onion
$15.00

East Side

Sliced Smoked Salmon, Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese, Avocado & Cucumber
$16.00

Brooklyner

Fresh Fried Eggs Sliced Smoked Salmon, Scallion Cream Cheese, Goat Cheese & Arugula
$15.00

Gotham

Sliced Smoked Salmon, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Beets & Horseradish Cream Cheese, Tomato, Arugula & Sweet Chili Jam
$16.00

Whitefish Sandwich

ACME Whitefish Salad, Beets & Horseradish Cream Cheese, Tomato & Arugula
$13.00

Jerusalem

Fresh Hummus, Tomato, Red Onions, Cucumber & Arugula
$7.00

Spicy Nagle

Crumbled Goat Cheese, Peppadew Peppers, Avocado, Nagle's Chili Jam
$8.00

Roadhouse

Jalapeo Cream Cheese, Smoked Ham, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Peppadew Peppers, Avocado & Arugula
$14.00

The Governor

Fresh Gourmet Tuna Salad, Arugula, Tomato, Onion & Applewood Smoked Bacon
$10.00

The Nellie

Chunky Style All White Meat Chicken Salad, Peppadew Peppers, Tomato, Onions, & Arugula
$9.00

Choose One Of Our Delicious Sandwiches

Choice of Pastries

Brownies
$3.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie
$4.00

Financiers Teddy Bears (GF)

Gluten Free
$3.00

Liege Waffles
$4.00

Banana Nut Muffin (Vegan GF)
$3.75

Chocolate Babka
$3.00

12oz. HOT
$3.00

16oz. HOT
$4.00

Choose Hot Coffee Size

Choose A Size

20oz. Iced
$5.50

Boylan Soda

12oz Bottles100% Pure Cane Sugar Soda
$3.50

Natalies

16oz.
$4.95

Poland Spring

16.9oz
$1.50

Red Jacket

12oz.
$4.50

Spindrift

12oz. Cans
$3.00

Topo Chico

12oz. Bottles
$3.50

Ciao Bella Coconut Water

All-Natural Hydration, Non-GMO, One Simple Ingredient
$3.95

Creamline Chocolate Milk
$3.35

Loop Mission - Cold Pressed Juices

We restore value to rejected fresh fruits and vegetables by transforming them into delicious and healty high-value, cold-pressed juices
$6.65

Iced Matcha Latte
$4.50

Iced Chai Latte
$4.50

Choice Of Drink

Choose Flavor

CHAI

This is a hot black tea with spices for infusion; it comes as a tea-bag in hot water like other teas. It is NOT a chai latte.
$3.50

EARL GREY
$3.50

ENGLISH BREAKFAST
$3.50

GREEN TEA
$3.50

HONEYBUSH & ROOIBOS
$3.50

Barbecue Chips
$3.00

Salt & Vinegar Chips
$3.00

Salted Chips
$3.00

Sour Cream & Onion
$3.00

Day Olds (6, assorted)

6 assorted bagels
$6.00

Dozen Bagels

Please provide your bagel choices in the special instruction box below
$27.00

Half Dozen Bagels

Please provide your bagel choices in the special instruction box below
$14.00

The Lox Box

1/2 Dozen Bagels, 1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese, 1/2 lb. ACME Sliced Salmon (* Serves a maximum of six individuals)
$45.00

Bagel Chips
$4.50

Choose Quantity

4oz. Cream Cheese

4oz Beets & Horseradish
$3.75

4oz Blueberry
$3.75

4oz Garlic & Herb
$3.25

4oz Jalapeno
$3.25

4oz Lox And Chive
$3.75

4oz Plain Cream Cheese
$3.00

4oz Scallion
$3.25

4oz Strawberry
$3.25

4oz. Tofu
$3.25

4oz Veggie
$3.25

8oz Beets & Horseradish
$7.00

8oz Blueberry
$7.00

8oz Garlic & Herb
$7.00

8oz Jalapeno
$7.00

8oz Lox & Chive
$7.00

8oz Plain Cream Cheese
$6.00

8oz Scallion
$7.00

8oz Strawberry
$7.00

8oz Tofu
$7.00

8oz Veggie
$7.00

8oz. Cream Cheese

Fish

4oz. Whitefish Salad

ACME
$4.50

8oz. Sliced Salmon
$16.00

8oz. Tuna Salad
$8.00

8oz. Whitefish Salad

ACME
$9.00

Partners Whole Bean

Filtered
$16.99

Nagles Mug

14oz. Ceramic Mug
$8.00

Retail